By Bernhard Langefeld and Jonas Zinn

Manufacturing faces a defining challenge: labor scarcity is no longer a cyclical concern—it is a structural reality. Europe's working-age population is projected to decline 18 percent by 2050, while China's working-age population is expected to shrink 24 percent over the same period. This demographic shift is colliding with rising costs and operational complexity, pushing automation to the top of the strategic agenda. Yet despite rapid advances in robotics and artificial intelligence, the "lights-out factory"—a production plant running with minimal human intervention—remains an aspiration rather than a universal reality. The question for manufacturers is no longer whether to automate, but how to systematically build autonomous capabilities while managing the constraints that persist across production and back-office operations.

The progress is real, but challenges remain

Encouragingly, leading manufacturers are already operating fully automated shifts in selected areas. MTU commissioned a fully automated airfoil production process capable of operating autonomously for up to 66 hours; Xiaomi operates a nearly fully automated production plant in Beijing with an estimated annual output of ten million phones. These examples demonstrate that lights-out operations are viable today - in the right contexts. Yet full autonomy remains elusive across most manufacturing environments. Assembly remains the bottleneck: product variance and the handling of flexible components - cables, tubes, packaging materials - continue to limit automation beyond niche applications. Back-office functions face equally stubborn obstacles: fragmented IT systems (ERP, PLM, MES poorly integrated), inconsistent data quality, and unplanned disruptions require constant manual intervention, preventing the seamless digital orchestration that full autonomy demands.

The reality is that progress has been uneven. Intralogistics has advanced significantly with autonomous mobile robots replacing manual material transports. Component manufacturing, particularly high-volume, low-mix machining and molding, can already achieve lights-out shifts through automated setup and changeover systems. Yet these pockets of success mask deeper systemic challenges that block broader automation. Manufacturers cannot simply deploy technology; they must fundamentally redesign how they operate.

Three strategic levers unlock incremental autonomy

We have identified three critical building blocks that enable manufacturers to move toward lights-out operations systematically, even when full automation remains out of reach in the short term. The first is process stabilization — the foundation for reliable autonomous operations. Stable, well-controlled processes supported by continuous improvement and AI-assisted use cases such as predictive maintenance and parameter optimization are non-negotiable prerequisites. Without process discipline, automation becomes fragile; with it, manufacturers can extend autonomous operations progressively.

The second lever is design for automation: embedding automation requirements early into product and process design. High-volume assemblers can simplify components, eliminate flexible components, and ensure automation-ready supply chains. Low-volume manufacturers can adopt platform strategies to increase volumes, enabling targeted automation. Design for automation transforms the economics of automation, making it viable even in complex environments.

The third lever is closing system gaps. Seamless data flow across production, quality, and maintenance systems enables predictive capabilities and reduces manual intervention during autonomous shifts. While a complete shift to a single IT ecosystem is impractical, targeted system integration - prioritizing high-value automation use cases - delivers significant value. AI-powered tools and cloud-based platforms are beginning to bridge fragmented IT landscapes, but traditional system integration remains essential for the foreseeable future.

A roadmap differentiated by manufacturing archetype

The strategic priorities differ by manufacturing type. Component manufacturers — Tier-3 suppliers, service providers — should prioritize process stabilization and closing system gaps. Back-office automation can unlock substantial value by reducing quotation-to-production cycles. High-volume low-mix assemblers should lead with design for automation: rethinking product architecture to ease assembly and ensuring suppliers deliver automation-ready components. Low-volume high-mix manufacturers must adopt platform strategies to carve out high-volume subsystems, then stabilize processes and close system gaps to enable selective lights-out capability.

The lights-out factory will not emerge overnight. Full autonomy remains a long-term vision. Yet manufacturers that address these three building blocks systematically and customized to their specific archetype can expand autonomous capabilities step by step, unlocking productivity gains while managing labor scarcity. The organizations that move now will reshape their competitive positioning for the next decade.

Register now to access the full study. Furthermore, you get regular news and updates directly in your inbox.